{
 "study": "R208",
 "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
 "effort": "high",
 "puppetmaster": "1.48.0",
 "final_sha256": "dd12e05a352b55eab022e471c027b261df289316a7a51eab759623d21949245b",
 "rules": {
  "1": "passes",
  "2": "holds",
  "3": "holds",
  "4": "holds",
  "5": "holds",
  "6": "no difference"
 },
 "follow_up_cost": {
  "U": 0.0,
  "exact_permutations": 70,
  "native_median": "2.5995422",
  "p": 0.014285714285714285,
  "pair_wins": 4,
  "pm_median": "0.73794300000000005"
 },
 "full_cost": {
  "holds": true,
  "native_sum": "30.4460920000000002",
  "pm_sum": "19.6848384000000001",
  "wins": 4
 },
 "cold_cost": {
  "holds": true,
  "native_sum": "20.5938588",
  "pm_sum": "16.6988924",
  "wins": 4
 },
 "cold_wall": {
  "holds": false,
  "native_sum": "2099.574657792051",
  "pm_sum": "1907.0952852900373",
  "wins": 2
 },
 "preference": {
  "holds": true,
  "losses": 0,
  "p": 0.001953125,
  "pair_majorities": 4,
  "wins": 9
 },
 "openrouter_judge_usd": "3.8262630",
 "layout": [
  {
   "id": "region_000",
   "column": 0,
   "row": 0,
   "biome": "meadow",
   "landmark": "windmill"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_001",
   "column": 1,
   "row": 0,
   "biome": "forest",
   "landmark": "watchtower"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_002",
   "column": 2,
   "row": 0,
   "biome": "desert",
   "landmark": "temple"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_003",
   "column": 3,
   "row": 0,
   "biome": "snow",
   "landmark": "lodge"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_004",
   "column": 0,
   "row": 1,
   "biome": "mesa",
   "landmark": "arch"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_005",
   "column": 1,
   "row": 1,
   "biome": "swamp",
   "landmark": "shrine"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_006",
   "column": 2,
   "row": 1,
   "biome": "coastal",
   "landmark": "lighthouse"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_007",
   "column": 3,
   "row": 1,
   "biome": "grassland",
   "landmark": "keep"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_008",
   "column": 0,
   "row": 2,
   "biome": "meadow",
   "landmark": "windmill"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_009",
   "column": 1,
   "row": 2,
   "biome": "forest",
   "landmark": "watchtower"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_010",
   "column": 2,
   "row": 2,
   "biome": "desert",
   "landmark": "temple"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_011",
   "column": 3,
   "row": 2,
   "biome": "snow",
   "landmark": "lodge"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_012",
   "column": 0,
   "row": 3,
   "biome": "mesa",
   "landmark": "arch"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_013",
   "column": 1,
   "row": 3,
   "biome": "swamp",
   "landmark": "shrine"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_014",
   "column": 2,
   "row": 3,
   "biome": "coastal",
   "landmark": "lighthouse"
  },
  {
   "id": "region_015",
   "column": 3,
   "row": 3,
   "biome": "grassland",
   "landmark": "keep"
  }
 ],
 "pm_cold_nodes": [
  {
   "admission_to_flow_s": 11.82929515838623,
   "flow_to_map_s": 1.0,
   "map_wall_s": 279.0,
   "world_judge_s": 125.0,
   "review_failures": 1,
   "builder_dispatch_count": 18,
   "builder_dispatch_median_s": 0.5345125198364258,
   "full_wall_s": 424.4788605830108
  },
  {
   "admission_to_flow_s": 9.688890933990479,
   "flow_to_map_s": 1.0,
   "map_wall_s": 512.0,
   "world_judge_s": 88.0,
   "review_failures": 2,
   "builder_dispatch_count": 22,
   "builder_dispatch_median_s": 1.1313869953155518,
   "full_wall_s": 620.7082625410112
  },
  {
   "admission_to_flow_s": 14.570127010345459,
   "flow_to_map_s": 1.0,
   "map_wall_s": 366.0,
   "world_judge_s": 100.0,
   "review_failures": 1,
   "builder_dispatch_count": 19,
   "builder_dispatch_median_s": 1.0591130256652832,
   "full_wall_s": 491.3974547079997
  },
  {
   "admission_to_flow_s": 11.599658012390137,
   "flow_to_map_s": 1.0,
   "map_wall_s": 265.0,
   "world_judge_s": 81.0,
   "review_failures": 0,
   "builder_dispatch_count": 16,
   "builder_dispatch_median_s": 0.9345030784606934,
   "full_wall_s": 370.51070745801553
  }
 ],
 "pre_host_reference": {
  "admission_to_flow_s": 137.8605499267578,
  "flow_to_map_s": 42.0,
  "map_wall_s": 678.0,
  "world_judge_s": 151.0,
  "review_failures": 2,
  "builder_dispatch_count": null,
  "builder_dispatch_median_s": 85.65379405021667,
  "full_wall_s": 1039.7612929344177
 },
 "follow_up_regions": [
  "region_001",
  "region_005",
  "region_015"
 ],
 "reps": [
  {
   "rep": 1,
   "arms": {
    "native": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r1-native-cold.json",
      "blocks": 22993,
      "usd": 5.6747,
      "wall_s": 546.2,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "d70558fca0d75c2222f815f4f8ce7e874ca0778e615852392069347af24671a2",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 23054036,
       "cached_input_tokens": 21945344,
       "output_tokens": 126276
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r1-native-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 22993,
      "usd": 2.7308,
      "wall_s": 378.8,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "1e84363e3ea36c54c3de0770e71856be43d436ec8c33ffb9f74d2c117d23a70e",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 13909526,
       "cached_input_tokens": 13445888,
       "output_tokens": 45897
      }
     }
    },
    "pm": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r1-pm-cold.json",
      "blocks": 24184,
      "usd": 3.855,
      "wall_s": 424.5,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "42b68f18aa8830c90fb4c3bbc7a4a02a48644bfe6cb8ae543ce35132c9b1e81e",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 9595780,
       "cached_input_tokens": 8705792,
       "output_tokens": 120444
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r1-pm-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 24184,
      "usd": 0.7462,
      "wall_s": 166.8,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "8f734b7fd25b309b542e3884df76b847d8183fc92056ad1587510b0a3700c628",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 3439322,
       "cached_input_tokens": 3287552,
       "output_tokens": 11392
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "votes": [
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's landmarks are more detailed and distinct, including windmill towers, arches, ziggurats with stairs, and lighthouses with windows, and its paths and water crossings read more clearly in the top view; World A's windmill floats as a disconnected element above its region."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A has clearer landmark silhouettes, including defined stone arches, windmill towers, and stepped pyramids, and its top view shows more consistent path connections. World B has a floating-looking windmill, mesa forms that read as cuboids, and less distinct features in the top view."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and polished voxel landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and more legible connected paths than World B."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete, clearly articulated landmarks, roads, and biome features, while World B contains visibly sparse or unfinished areas and less distinct structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "B shows more varied, detailed landmarks such as the desert arches, sculpted pyramids, a road bridge crossing water, and windmill towers. A's landmarks are simpler, with flat stepped pyramids, a floating-looking windmill post, and plainer arches, though A's roads read slightly more clearly."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are more detailed and distinct, with fuller windmills, arches, and pyramids, while World B has a sparse, thin windmill tower and less defined arches."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and polished assembly with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and more readable path connections, while World B shows more fragmented structures and less integrated detailing."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete landmark silhouettes, clearer connected paths and water crossings, and more cohesive terrain transitions, while World B has several sparse or unfinished-looking regions and less distinct structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's landmarks are more varied and detailed, including arches, stepped ziggurats with stairs, open keeps, a road bridge across the water, and better-integrated windmills, while World A's mesas and pyramids are simpler stacked blobs, although A's top-down layout reads slightly cleaner."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are more distinct, with clear desert arches, stepped pyramids, and a pagoda, and its roads read clearly in the top view, while World B's arches are blobby and its pyramids are simpler and more repetitive."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and polished modular landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, more legible paths, and better visual integration between regions, while World B appears more crowded and fragmented with less consistent structural clarity."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete landmark silhouettes, clearer paths and water crossings, and more cohesive biome detailing, while World B contains visibly sparse and unfinished-looking regions."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more articulated landmarks, including the stepped temples, the arches and a bridged road crossing over water, while World A's equivalents read as simpler massed shapes."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are more detailed and complete, with full windmills, a clear desert arch, layered terraced ziggurats, and a defined pagoda; World B has sparse windmill frames, a blobby arch, and a plain stepped pyramid."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents cleaner, more distinct landmark silhouettes and more legible connected paths, while World B's denser, overlapping structures and altered layouts make several regions harder to read."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete, detailed landmark silhouettes and richer biome transitions, while World B has visibly unfinished flat-topped structures and sparse terrain."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's revised regions show more articulated landmarks, including the stepped pyramid, the arch, and the open-walled keep with towers, and its paths are clearer, while World A has blockier, more cuboid landmark shapes."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more distinct, detailed landmarks, including arches, windmills, and pyramid structures, with clearer road layouts in the top view, while World B's revised regions read as blockier and less defined."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete landmark silhouettes, clearer open keep and building interiors, richer foliage and water integration, and more legible connected paths, while World B has several sparse or unfinished-looking landmark forms."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents more distinct, detailed landmark silhouettes and clearer connected routes, while World B has several sparse or slab-like regions that look less complete."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more developed landmarks: windmills with towers, an open keep with corner towers, stepped pyramids with paths, and a bridged wet crossing, while World A has flatter, simpler fills in several regions."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows clearer, more detailed landmarks such as intact arches, windmills and towers, with cleaner road layouts in the top view, while World B's windmill and arch regions look sparser and less legible."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more complete and intentional landmark silhouettes, clearer paths and water crossings, and better integration between regions, while both use similarly rich palettes."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete and varied landmark silhouettes, clearer paths and water crossings, and better-connected terrain, while World B has several visibly sparse or unfinished regions."
      }
     ]
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "rep": 2,
   "arms": {
    "native": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r2-native-cold.json",
      "blocks": 23247,
      "usd": 5.0588,
      "wall_s": 542.4,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "ae8e114ae2baa1675188de11073005d773a3ecaa3cae031e7a6e77ff35e66e5f",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 16905407,
       "cached_input_tokens": 15783296,
       "output_tokens": 123621
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r2-native-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 23247,
      "usd": 2.5515,
      "wall_s": 403.5,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "c3caf3753ccf51685b3475203095bfd226e01d6a076055fe553e8186171b3f9a",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 11640505,
       "cached_input_tokens": 11110400,
       "output_tokens": 38028
      }
     }
    },
    "pm": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r2-pm-cold.json",
      "blocks": 24242,
      "usd": 4.879,
      "wall_s": 620.7,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "03668ae0af65e806a2d3f185cc2d56ee78f7bb46d4c032e36a9342ffcd9166d3",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 12640044,
       "cached_input_tokens": 11540096,
       "output_tokens": 152512
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r2-pm-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 24242,
      "usd": 0.7923,
      "wall_s": 168.4,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "79c9cd941872da191abdb599967ed1b93bc16ad9dd7058c2119d6b3868889adf",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 3670278,
       "cached_input_tokens": 3514752,
       "output_tokens": 12975
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "votes": [
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show open interiors with corner towers in the top view, and its landmarks (lighthouses, windmills, arches) are more detailed, while World A's keeps read as clustered solid towers."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks read more distinctly, with clearer keeps that have corner towers around open courtyards, defined windmill blades, and tidy arches, while World B's keeps and windmills look cluttered and less legible."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents clearer landmark silhouettes, more coherent paths and water crossings, and a cleaner modular layout, while World B has more visually cluttered and less legible structures."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A has more distinct landmark silhouettes, richer biome-specific foliage and water, and clearer connected paths, while World B looks flatter and less detailed with several simplified or unfinished-looking structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show visible perimeter walls around open interiors with corner towers, and its windmills, lighthouses, and arches are more detailed. World A's keeps read as clustered solid towers."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A has more distinct landmark silhouettes: its keeps show clear perimeter walls with open interiors and corner towers, its arches are well formed and its lighthouses are detailed, while World B's keeps appear as clustered tower blobs and its landmarks read less clearly in the top view."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B presents more articulated landmark silhouettes, denser terrain transitions, and clearer path-and-water crossings, while both worlds use similarly effective biome palettes."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows richer landmark silhouettes, denser biome-appropriate foliage, and more clearly articulated paths and structures, while World B has flatter terrain, sparser vegetation, and several less-developed landmarks."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "B's keeps show open interiors with perimeter walls and corner towers, its windmills and arches are more detailed, and its water crossings are clearer, while A's keeps read as clustered solid towers."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clearer perimeter walls around open interiors with distinct corner towers, and its landmarks such as the windmills, arches and lighthouses have crisper silhouettes, while World B's castles look like clustered solid towers and its scene is more cluttered."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A has more coherent landmark silhouettes, clearer paths and water crossings, and a more polished, readable layout, while World B shows more fragmented and less refined structures."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents a more polished and cohesive environment with clearly defined landmarks, smoother terrain transitions, and more detailed structures compared to World B, which appears less refined and more fragmented."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show open interiors with corner towers, its lighthouses and windmills are more detailed, and its top view shows clearer road crossings over water, while World A's red keep reads as a cluster of solid blocks."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clearer perimeter walls, open interiors, and corner towers, and its landmarks have more detailed silhouettes, while World B's keeps and towers read as clumped solid masses with less distinct features."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and balanced voxel landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and better-defined paths, while World B shows more fragmented structures and less polished integration."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete landmark silhouettes and clearer connected paths, while World B has visibly simplified structures and less distinct features in several regions."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show open interiors with raised corner towers, and its windmills and lighthouses have more detailed silhouettes, while World A's red keep reads as a solid cluster and its plan view shows filled cuboid footprints."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clear perimeter walls with corner towers and open interiors, and its roads and landmarks read more distinctly in the top view; World B's keeps appear as clustered solid towers and its paths are less defined."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B presents more intricate, better-defined landmark silhouettes and richer biome detailing, with more convincing structural forms and integration than World A\u2019s simpler, flatter features."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more detailed, cohesive landmarks and terrain, with clearer paths, richer biome transitions, and better-defined structures such as the keep and windmills, while World B appears flatter and less refined in several regions."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "B's landmarks are more detailed and read clearly: the keeps have open interiors with corner towers, and the windmills, arches and lighthouses are richer. A's keeps and several landmarks look like flatter solid blocks."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clear perimeter walls, open interiors and corner towers, and its landmarks and roads read crisply, while several of World B's landmarks look like cluttered or solid crenellated masses."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive, readable repair with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain and path transitions, and more convincing connected structures, while World B shows more fragmented and less polished geometry."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete and detailed landmarks, clearer paths, and better-connected structures, while World B has visibly unfinished and less distinct features."
      }
     ]
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "rep": 3,
   "arms": {
    "native": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r3-native-cold.json",
      "blocks": 22848,
      "usd": 5.0183,
      "wall_s": 439.4,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "f5869446b4a21be4ef7f7eb96bbd91a1b90862e9c923bc76ea7bd372f574f7d9",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 16995189,
       "cached_input_tokens": 15793024,
       "output_tokens": 103462
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r3-native-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 22848,
      "usd": 2.6476,
      "wall_s": 366.9,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "4be3af555517aa4d9861e46c33837be586c5b8585e4130618311c5a0f6ea1327",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 12349175,
       "cached_input_tokens": 11825024,
       "output_tokens": 41675
      }
     }
    },
    "pm": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r3-pm-cold.json",
      "blocks": 24091,
      "usd": 4.0631,
      "wall_s": 491.4,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "57a6a9804a4d6c04f0649ca19aba350c71b8b0cc129d8e68505857be1e614717",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 10421556,
       "cached_input_tokens": 9469184,
       "output_tokens": 121141
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r3-pm-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 24091,
      "usd": 0.7178,
      "wall_s": 150.6,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "8fa1e0a6e88e590039dbf33d83c866d1dda033e217a97c76a18b15fdab6abfc0",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 3103257,
       "cached_input_tokens": 2952448,
       "output_tokens": 12092
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "votes": [
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "B shows more detailed landmarks such as keeps with open interiors and towers, snow trees, and a visible bridge crossing water, while A's landmarks and road crossings read as simpler and less finished."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clearer perimeter walls with corner towers and open interiors, and its roads and landmarks read more cleanly in the top view, while B's swamp regions appear more cluttered and less coherent."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents clearer landmark silhouettes, more distinct biome separation, and more readable connected paths than World B, whose denser central structures and irregular terrain make the layout harder to parse."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more distinct landmark silhouettes, richer terrain and foliage, and clearer path and water integration, while World B has flatter, more repetitive regions and less resolved structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows keeps with clearly open interiors and corner towers in the top view, visible bridge road crossings over water, and more detailed snow trees and windmills, while World A's top-view keep in one region appears sparse and its roads cross water less clearly."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's keeps show clearer perimeter walls with open interiors and corner towers, and its paths and landmarks read more cleanly, while World B's keeps and windmills look blockier and its top view has gaps in the keep walls."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B presents a more cohesive and polished voxel environment with richer architectural variety, clearer landmark silhouettes, and more deliberate biome transitions than World A."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents fuller biome coverage, more distinctive landmark silhouettes, and clearer connected paths and water crossings, while World B has visibly sparser regions and flatter, less resolved structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show clearer open interiors with corner towers, its wetland road crossings are visible with water on both sides, and its snow trees and pyramids are more detailed, while World A's top view shows some landmarks reading as flatter blocks."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's top view shows clearer continuous road grids and keeps with visible open interiors and corner towers, while several of World B's landmarks are blockier and its roads are less consistently traced."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A has clearer landmark silhouettes, more distinct biome separation, and more legible connected paths, while World B's larger central structures create heavier visual overlap."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and detailed modular landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, better-defined keeps with open interiors and corner towers, and more legible connected routes, while World B appears less refined and more fragmented in its structures and terrain."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "In B, the stepped pyramids, the keep with an open interior, and the wetland road crossing with a bridge over water read more clearly, while A shows more cuboid-like landmarks and less distinct crossings."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks read more distinctly, with detailed pagodas, stepped pyramids, and walled keeps, and its roads and water crossings show clearly in the top view, while World B has blockier or simplified landmarks in several regions."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B has more developed landmark silhouettes, denser vegetation, and more integrated terrain and paths, while World A looks flatter and more sparsely finished in several regions."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete and coherent landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and clearer connected routes, while World B has more fragmented structures and less resolved connections."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show clearer open interiors and corner towers, and its windmills and swamp crossings read more cleanly, while World A has blockier, flatter landmark interiors such as the solid-looking sand keep."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks read more distinctly: it has clearer arch silhouettes, a defined pagoda, and roads that stay continuous, while World B shows less legible structures, such as a thin, cluttered keep and blocky trees that obscure the paths."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and balanced voxel layout with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and more readable connected paths than World B."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete, distinctive landmarks with stronger silhouettes, richer biome detailing, and clearer connected routes, while World B contains more sparse, simplified, and visually unfinished areas."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "tie",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's keeps show clearer open interiors with corner towers, and its wet-biome road crossings and bridges read more distinctly in the top view, while World A's landmarks and roads are comparable but less clearly articulated."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "Both worlds show similar complete layouts with comparable landmarks, roads, water, and foliage, and no decisive visible difference in the revised regions."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents clearer landmark silhouettes, more coherent paths and water crossings, and more deliberate biome-specific detailing, while World B appears denser and less legible with several crowded or fragmented features."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents a more complete and cohesive voxel environment, with richer landmark silhouettes, clearer biome transitions, and more readable connected paths than World B."
      }
     ]
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "rep": 4,
   "arms": {
    "native": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r4-native-cold.json",
      "blocks": 22888,
      "usd": 4.8422,
      "wall_s": 571.7,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "74b0c3b4fdd4c370b5b5689307b6f7dd01818a787b8167f6a82fa625c65f81f9",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 15497574,
       "cached_input_tokens": 14408064,
       "output_tokens": 122234
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r4-native-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 22888,
      "usd": 1.9223,
      "wall_s": 343.5,
      "q": 78.75,
      "sha256": "0cf39f890d1caba9e3a98c2322416af36dda5b09e69e8df61ef79faf0047c874",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 8151222,
       "cached_input_tokens": 7750400,
       "output_tokens": 34563
      }
     }
    },
    "pm": {
     "cold": {
      "world": "data/r4-pm-cold.json",
      "blocks": 24366,
      "usd": 3.9018,
      "wall_s": 370.5,
      "q": 75.0,
      "sha256": "7f1f2ca1cf25013cc40f764cd913e843c7061c99c4977e300ef36f9e6ce5c1c3",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 8348274,
       "cached_input_tokens": 7393152,
       "output_tokens": 125224
      }
     },
     "follow_up": {
      "world": "data/r4-pm-follow_up.json",
      "blocks": 24366,
      "usd": 0.7297,
      "wall_s": 155.6,
      "q": 73.75,
      "sha256": "63c54c5bfdaaf7bf722af1b6ffae0848146e9f5884f7ae3b21f300973efcaf3c",
      "tokens": {
       "input_tokens": 3053075,
       "cached_input_tokens": 2893568,
       "output_tokens": 12130
      }
     }
    }
   },
   "votes": [
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more refined landmarks, including keeps with clear corner towers and courtyards, rounded lighthouse caps, and stepped pagodas, along with more varied and better-integrated paths and ports in its top view, while World A's windmills and some structures look sparser and blockier."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are cleaner and more distinct, with clearer keeps, lighthouses and paths, while World B's windmills and lighthouse tops look more cluttered and its center paths are less legible from above."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A has more distinct landmark silhouettes, richer terrain variation, and clearer regional structure, while World B appears flatter and less refined in its visible detailing."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents more complete and varied landmark silhouettes, clearer keep interiors and entrances, and richer biome detailing, while World B has several visibly simplified or less finished structures."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "tie",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "tie"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B has more refined landmarks, including open-interior keeps, detailed lighthouses, pagodas, and a temple, and its roads connect cleanly through each region, while World A's windmills and arches look rougher."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A has cleaner, more distinct landmarks, including clear windmills, banded lighthouses, keeps with towers, and tidy roads, while World B has cluttered windmill blades, a broken lighthouse top, and messier, less readable layouts."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and detailed voxel landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, smoother terrain transitions, and better-defined biome boundaries, while World B shows more fragmented structures and less polished integration."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents more coherent, detailed landmark silhouettes and clearer biome-specific structures, while World B has visibly sparse, fragmented, and less resolved features."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "cold",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more refined landmarks, including detailed lighthouses, keeps with open courtyards, and layered pagodas, along with cleaner path networks in its top-down view, while World A's windmills and wetland region look cruder and more cluttered."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows cleaner, more distinct landmarks, including tidy keeps with corner towers, crisp lighthouses, and windmills, along with clearer roads in the top view, while World B has messier lighthouse tops, cluttered foliage, and less legible keeps."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows stronger landmark silhouettes, more coherent biome transitions, clearer road and water crossings, and more deliberate material contrast than World A."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents a more cohesive and polished voxel landscape with clearer landmark silhouettes, richer biome color separation, and more visually connected paths and structures, while World B appears sparser and less refined in several regions."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 1,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's landmarks, including the windmill, pagoda, lighthouses, and keep with distinct corner towers, are more refined and its roads read cleanly in the top view, while A has cruder and odd windmill silhouettes and a flatter top-view layout."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are cleaner and more distinct, with neat windmills, lighthouses and a well-formed pagoda, while World B shows messier windmill sails, a cluttered swamp region and less legible paths in the top-down view."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B presents more cohesive and detailed landmarks, clearer paths, and a more polished, readable layout than World A."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows more complete landmark silhouettes, richer terrain and foliage, and clearer connected paths, while World B contains visibly sparse or unfinished regions."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 2,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's landmarks are more varied and detailed, with distinct pagodas, lighthouses with windows, and a keep with clear corner towers, and its regions blend more cohesively, while World A has repeated, cruder windmill and arch forms."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A's landmarks are cleaner and more distinct, with a tidy windmill, a clear arch, and well-formed keeps, while World B has messier windmill clusters, cluttered swamp regions, and less legible lighthouse tops."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more complete and distinct landmark silhouettes, including a clearly defined keep with perimeter walls and corner towers, better-connected paths and water crossings, and more cohesive biome transitions, while both worlds use similarly rich palettes."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A presents richer, more distinct landmark silhouettes, denser biome detailing, and clearer connected paths and water crossings, while World B leaves several regions visibly sparse or slab-like."
      }
     ]
    },
    {
     "phase": "follow_up",
     "scene": 3,
     "winner": "pm",
     "judges": {
      "claude": "pm",
      "kimi": "pm"
     },
     "reasons": [
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B's landmarks are more detailed, with clearer lighthouses, a keep with corner towers, layered pyramids and roofed cabins, and its paths and ports read more cleanly in the top-down view, while World A has blockier, flatter structures in several regions."
      },
      {
       "judge": "claude",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A shows cleaner, more distinct landmarks such as the keeps, windmills and lighthouses, and clearer road layouts in the top-down view, while World B has messier windmill and lighthouse shapes and more cluttered tiles."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "AB",
       "reason": "World B shows more coherent terrain transitions, better-defined landmark silhouettes, and more complete-looking structures with clearer paths and biome integration than World A."
      },
      {
       "judge": "kimi",
       "order": "BA",
       "reason": "World A has more coherent terrain and landmark silhouettes, with clearer paths and fewer visibly fragmented structures than World B."
      }
     ]
    }
   ]
  }
 ]
}